57 Comments
User's avatar
⭠ Return to thread
el gato malo's avatar

the data is just not good enough to get too deeply into that without GIGO issues.

there are all kinds of non-linear issues and massive heterogeneity in social graphs, number of connections, risk levels, etc and this interact in complex ways that we really cannot model.

SIR adjusts for this poorly or fails to account for it entirely. if you flip the right few superconncected nodes from spreader to blocker, you get wildly disproportionate effects etc.

we don't even have a good map of naturally generated immunity or any idea how many people have really been exposed. with an R this high, it's gotta be extremely high. this also makes assessing vaccine efficacy really difficult. there is so much acquired resistance and vax crossover with it.

the data her has been an utter mess and is hard to compare across regions and temporally.

this has rendered a lot of the sophisticated tools difficult to apply in any meaningful way.

Expand full comment