235 Comments
User's avatar
rural counsel's avatar

I'm was never on welfare not because I was luckier. It was because my parents were smart and thrifty and insisted on certain behaviors from their children, I learned to make good choices (sometimes painfully), I took advantage of my educational opportunities and studied hard, I learned delayed gratification, I was always working, and I didn't insist on a luxurious lifestyle dictated by morons.

I didn't do drugs, I didn't get anyone pregnant at an early age or outside marriage, and I didn't resent my teachers.

Ryan Gardner's avatar

Exactly. The best way to avoid poverty is to fear it.

Im quite comfortable, but its what gets my ass out of bed everyday at 4.30 AM.

Ryan Gardner's avatar

Yup. Other side of the coin

Dirt Merchant's avatar

Best lesson of my life… going broke at a young age.

Second best lesson… never forgetting lesson #1.

Amusings's avatar

"The best way to avoid poverty is to fear it." Perfect.

RathdrumGal's avatar

You had good parents. So did I.

1. Work before play.

2. If you can’t pay cash, you cannot afford it.

3. Save for a rainy day.

4. Thrift is a virtue.

Coach's avatar

I’ll go ya one step further:

My dad used to tell us kids that “Just because you have the cash in your pocket to pay for it, it doesn’t mean you can afford it!”

CaliforniaLost's avatar

I'm doing OK financially, so my dad likes to keep me grounded by saying, "You have more dollars than sense."

He's not totally wrong.

Dr Linda's avatar

Same. I also served in the military then used the GI bill to further my education

philipat's avatar

I agree with BC BUT, take a good look around you. We have no free markets (everything is manipulated) and we have a thoroughly corrupted system of crony capitalism.

It's much harder for youngsters today to get started and will get significantly worse again after the widespread implementation of AI. Sure there will always be opportunities for entrepreneurial innovators, but that represents a small minority. And it's getting harder to build a successful (profitable) SME and the crony system is stacked in favor of Large Corporations who are slowly taking over everything. So starting a career in business is much harder now that it used to be for youngsters.

If i put myself in their position, I can understand why Marxism appears to be an attractive alternative to crony capitalism. This is a dangerous, largely self-created, situation and we must address what we are going to do with the un-needed masses in the population, especially after AI. This is going to result in massive social unrest and insecurity unless we find solutions. The "elites" clearly see UBI and Total Information Awareness (that is, 24/7 total surveillance) as the solution but I don't think that is going to work. Most are not prepared to accept the Globalist/WEF mantra that "You will own nothing and you will be happy"?

SCA's avatar

It's reasonable that anyone might make some early mistakes. There's no excuse for not learning from them.

The Phoenician Muse's avatar

Sometimes, someone else’s bad choices cause poverty in others. That is my story: my ex decompressed into alcoholism and dependence on psych meds, losing his job, when the kids were six and five. Some will say that I should have run out and gotten full time employment (I was self-employed part time)…but one son had so many behavior problems that his special classroom required me to go to the school in person every week, and he could not be placed in day care. (As it turns out, this son’s problem was level 2 autism.). On top of that, I was suffering from cPTSD from the marriage. Eventually, I divorced the kids’ father, who then specifically sought and found a job that would help him to obscure his true income in order to reduce his child support burden. My ex paid less in child support for three children than did my grandfather in the 1960s, without adjusting for inflation. That was not the end of the story…it was just the ending segment of the first half or so, lol. So, yeah, poverty. I haven’t managed quite yet to get out of that yawning pit, but I am building my ladder.

troy milton's avatar

Your a a proud slave refusing to extort the weak. Pathetic

Steenroid's avatar

Great analysis. Sad that many are not educated enough to understand your thesis. But like welfare poor education is part of the plan.

signcut's avatar

Oh, they are 'edycated' alright; I like to say they are educated into ignorance.

YourGalapagosGullfriend's avatar

Indoctrinated and purposely distracted.

SCA's avatar

Gee thanks for demonstrating I think like an old person. So much for that spring in my step.

But anyway--I'm always baffled when all the Elizabeth Warrens amongst us start snarling about rich people spending trazillions on (often to be sure tacky) weddings etc. The fact the shrieking class always refuses to admit is that those trazillions are flowing out from the moneybags and into the economy.

Me--I'm not so silly as to want to be rich. More headaches in life I don't need. I just want to be comfortable. Just want to know that I can pay the bills each month without sweating, and that the bills should be for a modest pleasant life.

But I've never ever ever hated the wealthy. In actuality the worst people I know and this has been true all my life are the middle-class strivers conditioned by bad Hollywood films to think the mark of the upper crust is to torment the inferiors. The most courteous people I've ever met have been entrepreneurial millionaires.

And--from the mouth of she who keeps sayin' she's an ex-Noo Yawkuh now--all those years I paid them awful taxes in the silly naive belief I was at least contributing to the well-being of those less fortunate than my modest middle-class self--boy that turned out well. Mamdani the vast-estate-in-Uganda Communist gonna complete the natural progression of Bolshevism in the remake we really didn't need.

Dr Linda's avatar

Thinking along the same line, I mentioned in my comment that there are very wealthy Sibs in my family. They buy a lot, I don’t. It’s their money not mine. I have no reason to be angry or resentful.

If the wealthy want to throw a 3 ring circus wedding, they can afford. Let them.

I am guessing Warren is wealthy. How hypocritical to say what she said.

TrumpFan's avatar

Her current net worth listed at $8M.

So yes, hypocritical.

SCA's avatar

What the wealthy sometimes buy helps keep certain valuable skills alive in society, like parquet floor layers and blacksmiths. Well, maybe not so much here if they're importing the stuff from Europe but...

SnowInTheWind's avatar

* "The fact the shrieking class always refuses to admit is that those trazillions are flowing out from the moneybags and into the economy."

Exactly, and well said. Money is a tool, but the only kind of wealth that really matters is a reliably full belly, and there is only so much a stomach will hold. In that sense, we're all about equally well off if we aren't starving.

All the rest is just the channeling of relative power and perks. When the rich spend their money on frivolities, it just makes jobs and access to necessities for people who can cater to their whims.

SCA's avatar

It would be fun to know how much money a typical lavish wedding puts back into the economy both local and overall.

HdwJunkie's avatar

The other thing the left gets wrong is viewing the rich as Scrooge McDuck, lolling about on piles of valuables. The rich keep their assets at work, out in the economy, mostly used for good economic value creation. It’s not sitting in a bank earning 2%.

Chimp's avatar

And, mortgage market BS notwithstanding, even if it was just sitting in the bank earning 2%, then someone gets a house that they otherwise wouldn’t.

VerumSerum's avatar

“lost among this is any sort of root cause analysis.” So much of this debate is based in impressions, appearances, and parroted talking points. We need to make it about data. Ie where does wealth come from? Why was it that both my grandpas were able to build wealth after fighting in WWII? Clearly something changed in the system that prevents wealth by everyday people working hard as all the levers being throttled by the wizard behind the curtain. It’s like the light bulb “industry”…create new gov regs that disallow “non-green” bulbs on the market that are $0.99 and replace with LED that are $9.99. And meanswhile they run with zero budget while the rest of us have to live within actual financial boundaries…

bara.ex.nihilo's avatar

Those who lived through the Great Depression were often frugal and thrifty, always seeking ways to save.

sabu012's avatar

There’s more to it than that. Post WWII America was an economic miracle that may never be seen again. America won the war and came away largely unscathed compared to Europe and Asia. We got to rebuild the world on our terms and those benefits trickled down to the average person. Over time we abused and squandered that golden position and find ourselves in our current predicament.

HardeeHo's avatar

During WW2 the citizens banked a lot of labor to create all those weapons. We accumulated other wealth from sales. IOW the people sacrificed a lot. They were not able to spend away that wealth until the war ended, they did without.

That inherent prosperity lasted through the 60’s when children rebelled against the plenty. Those children grew up and now telling and teaching capitalism is bad. Never poor but they want everyone else to be poor thus the government largesse. Enough done doesn’t work.

Paula's avatar

My friend's grandparents washed and reused dental floss

Humdeedee's avatar

Sometimes I laugh at my own proclivities toward frugality, like when I'm rinsing out paper towels to re-use as needed for spot cleaning my kitchen floor, and saving gently used plastic bags that can be used for non-food type stuff. I've never washed and reused dental floss, but I would in a pinch.

Bare-Faced Plague-Spreader's avatar

I just reuse other people's teeth. (kidding)

Malcolm Johnston's avatar

We used to reuse those lead icicles on the Christmas tree.

Rosemary B's avatar

for dental floss?

nice!

Stephen Ungar's avatar

Is Elon Musk an innovator and entrepreneur or a rent seeker? He appears to be both. That being said, the chances that Elon can create wealth - even without government subsidies- is way better than average.

el gato malo's avatar

yeah, it's a fair point that musk has done quite a lot of subsidy slurping. tesla could never have been formed/grown without it.

but, and this is a meaningful but, at least it has resulted in huge amounts of innovation (far past what i would have expected). he's not sitting on a market and extracting money, he's pushing markets forward at speeds unseen in a long time.

Carl's avatar

Musk pumped his own company into the S&P 500 with call options bought against his own compensation (designed explicitly for such a scheme), he's rent seeking via the broken passive investing flows in 401ks. Not that Musk hasn't also done positive things (e.g. buying Twitter).

Rory Towler's avatar

What innovation?

Everything he's announced has started out and flopped to nothing. It's purely done to drive share price inflation until it all bursts and he gets TF out.

The only innovation is combining blatant fraud in the new industry of electric car manufacturing

Mitch's avatar

Musk is the predator/rentier that we are warned about.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Oct 30, 2025
Comment deleted
George Conrad Dick's avatar

Terrible indeed when electric lights were invented, internal combustion engines, and I suppose shovels and plows. Books for that matter too. Probably best that everyone just started from scratch...no need for tools and knowledge.

SnowInTheWind's avatar

That consideration needs to play into the analysis. A few "makers" invent AI, 30K working grunts lose their jobs with no obvious replacement sources of income, and the company owners can therefore become rentiers on the improved "efficiency."

Are the innovators and entrepreneurs actually creating value, or are they simply channeling the profits of it from one set of people to another?

Andrew VanLoo's avatar

Eventually, everyone will get the opportunity to create using AI and robotics. Base-level AI is free right now. It’s each person’s choice to make use of it (or not) to build something. The initial cost of being a builder has never been lower, and that will only continue when we can manipulate the physical world as easily as AI can manipulate software presently. Just imagine the amount of good that would happen if people would stop blaming others for success and start building their passion now. We could live in a world of unimaginable plenty if we look forward and not back.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Oct 31, 2025
Comment deleted
Dave's avatar

I think Elon gets a lot of greenie flack for not abiding by the gentleman's agreement of take the subsidy indefinitely and never actually produce anything.

Taking the subsidy and actually building something useful with it - a gas replacement EV that people would voluntarily buy without subsidy or force is the sort of thing that gets their free-money pipeline shut off.

Also interrupts a bunch of other plans around forcing everybody into cities and controlling travel.

Dr Linda's avatar

I believe that is a fair assessment. I also think it’s perhaps the most successful position.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Oct 30, 2025Edited
Comment deleted
Debbie Wagner's avatar

It goes without saying that a company has to have talented employees to successfully manufacture and market their products, but in no way does that detract from gato’s point that the person who has a great idea plus the confidence, persistence, and work ethic to build a business is the person who deserves the credit and the greatest financial reward for taking the risks inherent in business development. These business leaders and innovators are the economic engine we must have to drive our economy. They should be celebrated.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Oct 30, 2025
Comment deleted
Debbie Wagner's avatar

There are a couple business principles at play here that your position is overlooking. First, the rewards of starting a business must be commensurate with the risks. Large risk, large potential reward. Little risk, little potential reward. A business owner takes all the risk. Non-stock holding employees, no matter how talented or valuable, do not have any risk and are compensated for their direct contributions to the success of a company.

The second principle is leverage. No one gets rich charging by the hour. Few get rich on a salary. Entrepreneurs are incentivized to take risk by knowing they can attain wealth by leveraging the labor of their employees. There is nothing wrong with this. It’s how companies grow, expand, and create jobs.

Maybe you disagree with this. That’s ok. These ideas seem fundamental to me. We will just have to agree to disagree.

Enjoy your day!

Treemcg's avatar

I forget which Democrat administration (Carter or Clinton) imposed higher taxes on yachts and private planes, but they quickly lowered them. They had put all the people who had jobs in those industries out of work.

Mark Hedlund's avatar

My recollection is that H.W. Bush upped the taxes on luxuries.

KHP's avatar

Bush the First might have signed it into law, but Congress passed the tax changes.

I was there for that particular bloodbath - - working for a software company specializing in point of sale and work order software for the boat yard industry.

cat's avatar

"Read my lips," indeed.

Awilson's avatar

I met a man who was laid off when his employer, a boat building company, closed due to those new taxes. It was a pretty clear example of cause and effect.

Brandon is not your bro's avatar

Quote Origin: Give a Man a Fish, and You Feed Him for a Day. Teach a Man To Fish, and You Feed Him for a Lifetime.

AndyinBC's avatar

My bride decorated my man cave with a sign that asserts, "Give a man a fish, he eats for a day. Teach a man to fish, and he will sit in the boat and drink beer all day."

Bronan Co’Brien's avatar

I heard something like that.

Build a man a fire, you warm him for an evening; set a man on fire and you warm him for the rest of his life.

Sorry. Couldn't resist.

Rikard's avatar

And then fine his estate for the release of CO2.

Because the climate, you know.

Glen Thomson's avatar

That went straight into the sun, fast

golftdibrad's avatar

If you chop your own firewood it warms you twice.

Rikard's avatar

Fell the tree = 1

Cut it up = 2

Haul the pieces home = 3

Split and cut = 4

Cleave and stack = 5

If you do it manually, that is.

(Just had to jump at the chance for some bragging, since I do get my firewood the old-fashioned way.)

Rosemary B's avatar

this is a different generation.

I do not think any of us grew up knowing there was free stuff available. Did you know that?

Honestly, I believe I was not that kind of smart enough to know this was a thing.

In 1984, my husband's brother and sis in law (in California) adopted a child that was the offspring of a drug addict and multi racial. I do not know..... they told us that, and I am sure they told the daughter, so she always grew up inferior, even though she went to a private school. Some how, she ended up making friends with losers because she felt she was a loser.

We never kept in touch very much, but years later, she moved to Marquette, Michigan (U.P) to be close to her then divorced father.

Still with me?

She got a place of her own, I think she worked at a fast food place, encouraged by her auntie democrat that lived up there too, applied for housing. Then she got pregnant by some rich kid in the area, wealthy family. then she learned through some magical system of getting so much free stuff, she had two tvs!!! and a closet full of clothes.

I do not know if she had a car bk then.

The parents of the rich kid, somehow made a deal with her to give that little boy up for adoption to the parents of the rich kid. This was a good thing because she was already involved with some rough guy that was from Richmond Virginia, not sure what he was doing up there.

Eventually she moved to Virginia with that guy.

We have not heard from her in ages. Honestly, for our family, it was just too mentally overwhelming.

"long story short" people who get into this system of dependency never leave, and they learn all of the ways to continue to live that life. They have no will to leave.

Glen Thomson's avatar

The strangeness of it all. I can relate to the sense of bafflement you describe when watching someone paint themselves into a corner. If you talked to her, and had enough time to get to know her, she may very well believe she's living her best life, just like the rest of us. Or perhaps she is very determined to make improvements in her life, but those "improvements" don't make sense in the bigger picture. Cue the feather blowing on the wind...

Bare-Faced Plague-Spreader's avatar

Also says something about nature vs. nurture, not sure what. If only they had a twin who was told since birth they were the offspring of Midas.

AndyinBC's avatar

One might add, to borrow vocabulary from the left, "And they are strongly disincentivized". From leaving that is.

YourGalapagosGullfriend's avatar

This would not solve all of the money problems overnight, but:

1. We need to bring back Home Economics for our high schooler (also, shop class, but that's a TED talk for another day). Learning how to value your money and create a household budget would likely cut down on the amount of Irishman coming out of our public indoctrination centers.

2. We also need to make Thomas Sowell's Basic Economics required reading for high schoolers as well. Make graphic novel and Golden Book versions, so the kids can start getting in it from the start.

3. If I were in charge, I'd also make Gifted Hands by Dr. Ben Carson required reading as well. Politics aside, Carson's mother Sonia was an incredible example of a woman who would not let her children be brought down by their circumstances. We could all benefit from her strength and loving determination with her sons.

Rosemary B's avatar

Now let's talk about Government Jobs. there are plenty of jobs available for ppl that have had nearly no education. Then there are the ones that have had education but are lazy and not ambitious. They get clerk and secretary jobs. They do nothing all day, but they work for the government and once they are in the US government system, it is very difficult nearly impossible to fire them.

My significant other was a contracts lawyer with DIA. He has had some of the worst secretaries.

It took him several years to fire them. They usually just get transferred but that Government job is a comfy situation for many.

dave walker's avatar

I spend entirely too much time worrying about these very things. I’m feeling less like an outsider now that you published this essay. Highly accurate and greatly appreciated. We just need momentum to stop the madness and return to normalcy 🤞🙏 Thank you for this piece.

Liz LaSorte's avatar

It’s common sense that spending other people’s money is never sustainable. Yet, here we are, continuing to increase the national debt each day and it now is past 38 trillion dollars:

https://lizlasorte.substack.com/p/let-them-eat-ballroom-gold-dust?r=76q58

Tim Mahl's avatar

When the “Takers” outnumber the “Makers” , and it won’t be long, it will all come tumbling down.

Charles weaver's avatar

When the takers make up most of Congress as well there will be no real effort to change things

bara.ex.nihilo's avatar

Except there will be nothing to take.....and We the People will finally awaken from this induced coma with great ire at the government.

David Westall's avatar

We are past that point already. Quick math. Total State and local govt spending roughly 5.7T and Total federal spending 6.9 divided by 330m people is roughly 38k per person. Avg household size is 2.51 so roughly 95k per household is your households share. Approx 45% of households make that much or more. Unless you pay more than 95k in combined fed (fica, med, income) and state and local taxes you are a taker. Which of course means that very few people are the makers.

SnowInTheWind's avatar

That assumes that each household is actually the beneficiary of 95k in government spending. In fact, that will vary considerably, just as income and taxation do. People can be paying much less than that and still be paying more in than the value they receive from their government.

Tim R's avatar

From your lips to God's ears. You might even get the secret handshake from Ayn Rand for this commentary.

Charles weaver's avatar

If you provide help or assistance to someone in need on a temporary basis it’s most often appreciated. Continue indefinitely and they will resent and eventually hate you.

It’s human nature

Welfare should be temporary and have restrictions

Rid the program of lazy moochers and there will be an abundance of to help those really in need

Karen Watson's avatar

I think on this matter often, thank you for putting forth such a compelling solution.