52 Comments
User's avatar
⭠ Return to thread
jjinUK64's avatar

I agree, I'm actually very unclear on why she lost that race. Her message discipline was excellent, her offer was clear and compelling -- her rallies showed that was connecting with people as a real leader, someone people would follow. Polling showed she was 'cutting through' with her clear and heartfelt platform.

By contrast Whitmer was bitchy and short, and got hamstrung in some of her own lies in the debates. Polling showed her losing steam as people saw more of her inauthenticity.

I still don't get how this one went sideways.

Expand full comment
Ryan Gardner's avatar

FREE SHIT!

That's the 800 lb guerilla

Expand full comment
Keahi's avatar

Tribal allegiance, free shit, and the general dumbing down. People have become stupid, thanks to our ever-degenerating education system. And spoiled. Sorry, but it's true. Maybe after a war on our soil - God forbid - or some serious shortages, empty shelves and rationing, the sort of thing that Europe has gone through, people will get smart. Might be too late though - the influx of thousands of people through our border, who have everything handed to them including cell phones they don't make a single payment on, ever - I don't know. I'm so disheartened. The band keeps playing but the ship is going down.

Expand full comment
Ryan Gardner's avatar

Me too.

Republicans are so good at snatching defeat out of the jaws of victory.

Expand full comment
Keahi's avatar

As for dumbing down - all we have to do is look at the incredible percentage of people who bought into the "pandemic" fraud.

Expand full comment
BradK (Afuera!)'s avatar

Bought into or simply too passive to stand against it?

Now that the panicdemic has more or less run its course (and the perpetrators are seeking a blanket pardon) expect the global warming fraud to get more and more play over the next two years.

Expand full comment
Ryan Gardner's avatar

Could not agree more

Expand full comment
Ryan Gardner's avatar

100% true

Expand full comment
Mrs. McFarland's avatar

Yup! Thanks Lindsay Graham!, what the hell was that all about? Boeing keeps your slimy pockets filled, so why was it necessary to call for a National Ban on abortion???? Huge douche move.

Expand full comment
BradK (Afuera!)'s avatar

Not so much snatching defeat as unable to offer a different (and more appealing) carrot. "At least we're not Democrats" is hardly a deal closer. And so long as the GOP remains locked in a civil war between the country club elites and the barbarian MAGA hoards the self-harm will only continue I'm afraid. The Democrat message of a utopian unity under Marxism is apparently more appealing.

Expand full comment
Mrs. McFarland's avatar

“the country club elites and the barbarian MAGA hoards “.... yup, and that’s why this party Girl has no Party. And why the # of Independents continues to grow. I wish I could be optimistic about a third party, but SHOCK! I don’t trust politicians, period.

Expand full comment
Ryan Gardner's avatar

I know. I wish it were different. But you're right.

Expand full comment
Keahi's avatar

Oh they excel at it. My sig oth has been saying this all along - don't get your hopes up. Maybe now he will get behind moving to Mexico

Expand full comment
BradK (Afuera!)'s avatar

At this point Mexico is probably safer than most large American cities.

Expand full comment
Keahi's avatar

For the most part. You do know where you stand.

Expand full comment
jim's avatar

they offer no real solutions as a national party, and are run by feckless, bought off empty suits(see Mitch McConnell). DeSantis is a leader, and he produced tangible results. He proved it can be done. I know of many lifelong libs that voted DeSantis down here in Florida, especially cops and fire fighters. He is what a real leader looks like, and he offers a message that resonates with 60% of the population.

Expand full comment
Ryan Gardner's avatar

Agree 1000%

You'll not find a bigger DeSantis fan than my family. We live in Florida. He is the future. It's just a matter if the suits get behind him or try to take him down.

Expand full comment
AM Schimberg's avatar

...and cheating.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Nov 9, 2022
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Lemuel's avatar

Ww3 might do the trick. Unfortunately the USA is guaranteed to lose.

Expand full comment
Laura Garcia's avatar

That happened in Maine too. Free education, $850 refund checks (our money to begin with) and hey look I balanced the budget (with COVID funds that will still come out of our pocket)….

Too many don’t even understand the political process and how our government was structured.

Expand full comment
AndyinBC's avatar

Are you old enough to remember, back in the prehistoric era, when schools were allowed to actually teach, curricula included subjects like "civics", and "history", and "economics". We learned, in the elementary grades, how government was supposed to work, and how it had, and had not, worked in the past. An some of us, the lucky ones, when we reached high school, were even taught how government actually worked.

Today - all of these subjects have been banned.

Expand full comment
bunnieknit's avatar

🤬🤬🤬

Expand full comment
The Inmate's avatar

They cheated. It is as clear to me as when people ask, why are we having all these sudden deaths? It the vaccines.

Whitmer won because these people cheated and they will continue cheating unless something drastically changes.

Expand full comment
Urbacka's avatar

She lost her emergency powers last year and that saved her. She laid low, which seems a winner for politicians, had a huge bank, ran a tremendous number of ads telling voters Dixon was dangerous, and the power of incumbency is huge. In Michigan we've gone Blanchard (dem, 2 terms), Engler (rep, 2 terms), Granholm (dem 2 terms), Snyder (rep, 2 terms) and now Whitmer (dem, 2 terms). I suspect we may see a republican next time.

Dems know how to message better. They supposedly care and that connects. And Dems are in it to win it. They are ruthless.

Expand full comment
Dr. K's avatar

Dems own the female sympathy vote. (Fetterman had a 15% female win according to CBS -- good reason to vote for people is you feel sorry for them, I guess.)

So the solution is to put up even worse, more sympathetic characters? I just do not get it. Of course, Pennsylvania also elected (by a landslide) a candidate that was dead. May say something about that state in general.

Expand full comment
Urbacka's avatar

I don't understand how people think. I know when I look around in my day to day life, there are a lot of stupid people. I don't mean that as an insult, just an observation. And a lot of self importance. It is supposed to impress me that women care about the unfortunate. Only if they are a nun or something. And I am a woman.

Expand full comment
Urbacka's avatar

I wish women didn't have the right to vote. I think the world might work as well and we could still be women. I am impressed with Kari Lake. I think she is unusual for a female politician. She has a commanding presence that isn't just about being itchy.

Expand full comment
SCA's avatar

Societies always grow too big, eventually, to successfully manage the diversity of personality and intelligence any population shows.

It's not so bad to be a stupid plowman if a smart one teaches you how to do the job. You can still have a decent life with little harm to the rest of the village.

Gets worse when you scale up.

Expand full comment
Urbacka's avatar

Like Dr. Ball's Systemantics - systems can operate for a long time in failure mode. I think he observed no complex system designed from scratch can work, it will always fail. By tearing down what we have to replace it, I sense we may test this theory.

Expand full comment
SCA's avatar

Everything in life goes through cycles. We tend to dislike some permanent truths because they're not fixable.

People get rich writing books about the obvious basic workings of the universe and throwing in what they think are startling revelations.

Hives are constructed beautifully. Eventually they get unwieldy and somebody has to move out and start over.

Expand full comment
Natalie's avatar

I don't know about that. Proposal 2 passed, which means the Michigan Constitution now mandates no voter ID, drop boxes, and all manner of election-stealing mechanisms. It just got much harder for a Republican to win in Michigan.

Expand full comment
jim's avatar

this is the go to move in states run by democrats. Get as many votes cast not at the polls as possible. remove any safeguard that makes fraud more difficult. Call any dissent "racist" and "voter suppression". watch weak kneed, feckless republican politicians fall in line.

Expand full comment
Urbacka's avatar

Republicans need to get smart fast.

Expand full comment
0311's avatar

Good luck with that.

Expand full comment
Ruth H's avatar

They don’t message better—they lie and don’t get called out for it. Media and social media protects them. Their caring is always fake and their followers are too ignorant to see it. When abortion is praised as birth control instead of the murder of a child, then these women who vote for ‘their rights’ for abortion instead of their right to motherhood should be pitied.

Expand full comment
jjinUK64's avatar

Good insight, thank you

Expand full comment
Shelle's avatar

Yes, I have thought for a long time that Republicans need to do a better job messaging compassion. I vote Republican and do so out of genuine care for the good of others. I think there are countless Republicans like me. Why can't they do a better job showing how conservative policies help everyone thrive and lift up struggling minorities? Because they actually do!

Expand full comment
Ruth H's avatar

Cheating always helps Dems. They always cheat and never forget that they do.

Expand full comment
freelearner's avatar

The incessant ads on YouTube repeating that Dixon is against abortion even in cases of rape and incest likely played a role even though it was irrelevant, because abortion rights were up for referendum. People are dumb that way.

Expand full comment
Urbacka's avatar

They were really annoying too.

Expand full comment
Ruth H's avatar

So true.

Expand full comment
Adam Vossen MD's avatar

Tribal allegiance

Expand full comment
SpankinRedAss's avatar

https://theconservativetreehouse.com/blog/2022/11/09/big-picture-2020-midterm-elections-highlights-distinct-difference-between-ballots-and-votes/

I think that link explains a large part of it very well. Add on the unaccountable "national security" apparatus that seems to have a controlling interest in both parties and it seems to me that we have as much explanation as needed for our current debacle.

Any suggestion of a diminished federal government will assuredly be treated as a "threat to democracy", those espousing it de facto enemies of the state and the ever-growing arsenal of beaurocracy turned against them.

Expand full comment
The Inmate's avatar

Thanks for this link. I appreciate it.

Expand full comment
POZIOMKA's avatar

It’s called an election fraud.

Expand full comment
Urbacka's avatar

I would say it happens in every election. I am pretty sure JFK cheated and Nixon actually won. It is as old as elections. Lincoln won the nomination with a little trickery.

Expand full comment
Leanne C's avatar

‘If Then’ a book written by veteran journalist Jill Lepore has some interesting insights around the JFK election process FYI

Expand full comment
Urbacka's avatar

thank you. I haven't heard of it. I'll have to check it out.

Expand full comment
Keahi's avatar

One word. Detroit.

Expand full comment